Capital One Financial Analysts Reduce Earnings Estimates for Enerplus Co. (NYSE:ERF)

Capital One Financial Analysts Reduce Earnings Estimates for Enerplus Co. (NYSE:ERF)

→ Uncommon Passive Profits Expense (Located on a Golf Class) (From Oxford Club)pixel

Enerplus Co. (NYSE:ERF – Get Score) (TSE:ERF) – Capital Just one Fiscal dropped their Q1 2023 earnings estimates for Enerplus in a investigation observe issued to buyers on Tuesday, March 14th. Money 1 Economical analyst B. Velie now anticipates that the oil and all-natural fuel enterprise will submit earnings of $.66 for each share for the quarter, down from their prior estimate of $.70. The consensus estimate for Enerplus’ existing complete-yr earnings is $2.71 for each share. Funds Just one Economic also issued estimates for Enerplus’ Q2 2023 earnings at $.62 EPS, Q3 2023 earnings at $.67 EPS, Q4 2023 earnings at $.69 EPS, FY2023 earnings at $2.64 EPS, FY2024 earnings at $2.78 EPS and FY2025 earnings at $2.92 EPS.

ERF has been the matter of a variety of other investigation reports. Scotiabank cut their concentrate on rate on shares of Enerplus from C$26.00 to C$25.00 in a investigation report on Tuesday, January 17th. Barclays assumed protection on shares of Enerplus in a analysis report on Wednesday, January 18th. They set an “equal fat” ranking for the firm. Two investigation analysts have rated the stock with a maintain score and five have assigned a obtain score to the company’s stock. According to knowledge from MarketBeat, the stock has an regular ranking of “Average Get” and an common concentrate on rate of $24.75.

Enerplus Stock Performance

Shares of ERF opened at $14.50 on Wednesday. The corporation has a present-day ratio of .81, a quick ratio of .81 and a debt-to-fairness ratio of .17. The stock has a marketplace cap of $3.16 billion, a P/E ratio of 3.79 and a beta of 2.19. The corporation has a 50-day shifting ordinary of $16.69 and a two-hundred day relocating typical of $16.61. Enerplus has a 12-month reduced of $11.00 and a 12-month significant of $19.23.

Enerplus Will increase Dividend

The company also lately declared a quarterly dividend, which will be paid out on Wednesday, March 15th. Investors of record on Monday, March 6th will be issued a $.111 dividend. This represents a $.44 dividend on an annualized foundation and a produce of 3.06{21df340e03e388cc75c411746d1a214f72c176b221768b7ada42b4d751988996}. This is an maximize from Enerplus’s past quarterly dividend of $.06. The ex-dividend date of this dividend is Friday, March 3rd. Enerplus’s payout ratio is presently 5.74{21df340e03e388cc75c411746d1a214f72c176b221768b7ada42b4d751988996}.

Institutional Traders Weigh In On Enerplus

A amount of institutional investors have recently acquired and bought shares of ERF. Belpointe Asset Administration LLC bought a new stake in Enerplus throughout the fourth quarter really worth around $25,000. CWM LLC procured a new stake in Enerplus through the third quarter truly worth approximately $27,000. Bessemer Group Inc. procured a new posture in shares of Enerplus in the fourth quarter valued at $35,000. Quantbot Systems LP obtained a new place in shares of Enerplus in the 1st quarter valued at $37,000. Lastly, Rockefeller Cash Management L.P. boosted its stake in shares of Enerplus by 323.{21df340e03e388cc75c411746d1a214f72c176b221768b7ada42b4d751988996} in the fourth quarter. Rockefeller Money Administration L.P. now owns 3,012 shares of the oil and organic gas firm’s inventory valued at $53,000 immediately after buying an additional 2,300 shares during the time period. 53.01{21df340e03e388cc75c411746d1a214f72c176b221768b7ada42b4d751988996} of the stock is at this time owned by hedge funds and other institutional buyers.

Enerplus Corporation Profile

(Get Score)

Enerplus Corp. engages in the exploration and generation of crude oil and purely natural gas. It conducts functions in Willston Basin, Marcellus Shale, and Canadian Waterfloods. The company retains passions in North Dakota, Colorado, Pennsylvania, and in the provinces of Alberta and Saskatchewan. The company was founded in 1986 and is headquartered in Calgary, Canada.

Showcased Stories

Earnings History and Estimates for Enerplus (NYSE:ERF)

This prompt information warn was generated by narrative science technologies and monetary information from MarketBeat in order to offer audience with the quickest and most correct reporting. This tale was reviewed by MarketBeat’s editorial team prior to publication. Make sure you send out any thoughts or remarks about this tale to contact@marketbeat.com.

Right before you take into consideration Enerplus, you are going to want to hear this.

MarketBeat retains keep track of of Wall Street’s prime-rated and ideal carrying out study analysts and the stocks they advise to their purchasers on a day-to-day basis. MarketBeat has determined the 5 shares that best analysts are quietly whispering to their clientele to buy now ahead of the broader current market catches on… and Enerplus was not on the checklist.

When Enerplus now has a “Average Buy” score amongst analysts, leading-rated analysts believe these 5 stocks are superior purchases.

Perspective The 5 Stocks Below

5G Stocks: The Path Forward is Profitable Cover

Oil prices crater as fear ripples through financial market

Oil prices crater as fear ripples through financial market

As fears above the banking procedure weigh on markets globally, the price tag of oil has arrive underneath important pressure in modern days with WTI crude oil, the U.S. benchmark, falling under $67 on Wednesday, its least expensive price given that November 2021.

On Wednesday, WTI was off just about 7{21df340e03e388cc75c411746d1a214f72c176b221768b7ada42b4d751988996} to trade as low as $66.47 a barrel. As lately as March 6, WTI traded arms north of $80. Brent crude oil, the intercontinental benchmark, traded as low as $72.60 a barrel on Wednesday.

This week’s collapse in oil price ranges comes as the hottest knowledge on oil stockpiles in the U.S. present a regular create in inventories amid what Money Economics’ main commodities economist Caroline Bain referred to as “subdued domestic demand” in a be aware to purchasers on Wednesday.

Facts from the American Petroleum Institute out Tuesday confirmed inventories rose for the 10th-straight 7 days for the 7 days ending March 10, whilst the Energy Details Administration’s weekly petroleum report out Wednesday confirmed a construct in crude oil inventories final 7 days, noting inventories are working 7{21df340e03e388cc75c411746d1a214f72c176b221768b7ada42b4d751988996} higher than the 5 yr average.

Crude oil inventories have been steadily rising this year amid a

Crude oil inventories have been steadily growing this 12 months amid a “subdued domestic demand” ecosystem. (Resource: Capital Economics)

Bain also pointed to the Biden administration’s final decision on Monday to approve a massive drilling job in Alaska as a indication a lot more source could be coming onto a current market already not struggling with a shortage of oil.

“The acceptance was for a pared-back again job and it will even now facial area lawful troubles, but it is considerable since President Biden has damaged his marketing campaign guarantee to ban all drilling on federal lands,” Bain wrote. “When absolutely operational at 180,000 [barrels per day], it would indicate a 40{21df340e03e388cc75c411746d1a214f72c176b221768b7ada42b4d751988996} rise in Alaska’s oil output to around 620,000 bpd.”

U.S. President Joe Biden makes a statement about gasoline prices and oil company profits in the Roosevelt Room as U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen listens at the White House in Washington, U.S., October 31, 2022. REUTERS/Leah Millis

U.S. President Joe Biden will make a assertion about gasoline selling prices and oil organization revenue in the Roosevelt Space as U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen listens at the White Residence in Washington, U.S., Oct 31, 2022. REUTERS/Leah Millis

The most recent drop in oil also has some echoes of the worry viewed in oil marketplaces in the spring of 2020.

Oil was sold aggressively that spring as a international recession induced by the pandemic muddied the need picture. But the rapid fall in the price tag of oil eventually made serious-world storage mismatches that resulted in WTI falling to adverse $40 a barrel as traders worked to steer clear of taking pressured shipping and delivery of oil they could not retail store.

A surge in the greenback also pressured oil rates Wednesday. The dollar experienced observed pretty muted trading during the initial fallout from Silicon Valley Bank’s failure, but was strengthening broadly on Wednesday as Credit rating Suisse’s most recent struggles trigger expanding fears about the international fallout from modern U.S. bank failures.

Click right here for the most up-to-date inventory market news and in-depth examination, which include situations that shift stocks

Study the hottest economical and business enterprise information from Yahoo Finance

CGI Federal Books NRC Contract for Financial Management Systems Support; Stefan Becker Quoted

CGI Federal Books NRC Contract for Financial Management Systems Support; Stefan Becker Quoted

CGI Federal has received a possible 5-year, $40 million contract from the Nuclear Regulatory Fee for system modernization aid.

Under the indefinite-shipping and delivery/indefinite-quantity agreement, CGI Federal is anticipated to deliver ongoing aid to NRC economic management methods, which by now use the company’s Momentum federal company source setting up tool, CGI Federal introduced from Fairfax, Virginia on Tuesday.

Stefan Becker, senior vice president and regulatory organizations small business device guide at CGI Federal, highlighted the organization’s 10 years-prolonged heritage of supporting the agency’s monetary administration operations.

“NRC entrusted CGI Federal to go its economic management system to the general public cloud a long time in the past, earning the company one of the earliest adopters of cloud for its ERP techniques. Today, commission industry experts can accessibility data from NRC’s entire money operation via this single, cloud-based, company-vast system,” he said.

As purchased by the agreement, CGI Federal will increase its work to present an built-in managed solutions ERP providing for the NRC’s Office of the Main Money Officer. The procedure is meant to align with the NRC’s unique mission and processes to assistance the agency’s initiatives to assure transparency, accountability and performance across its functions as it moves to meet up with changing authorities monetary demands.

“CGI Federal’s continued assist enables the successful and well timed procedure of company-vast money administration processes and empowers NRC to execute in opposition to its critical general public environmental and protection goals,” said Vishal Ranjan, the contractor’s vice president of consulting expert services.

In 2012, CGI Federal transferred the agency’s Monetary Accounting Built-in Management Info Systems to Momentum below a $21.28 agreement, symbolizing the company’s support for the NRC’s early attempts to move its fiscal programs to the cloud.

CGI’s Momentum platform has been adopted by various other federal businesses, which include the Department of Justice. In February 2022, the business secured a $250 million blanket invest in settlement and an first $133.9 million undertaking purchase to run, deal with and sustain the department’s Unified Financial Management Method, which was executed making use of Momentum, and its Unified Asset Administration Process.

Morgan Stanley testing OpenAI-powered chatbot for its financial advisors

Morgan Stanley testing OpenAI-powered chatbot for its financial advisors

OpenAI brand seen on screen with ChatGPT web page shown on mobile witnessed in this illustration in Brussels, Belgium, on December 12, 2022.

Jonathan Raa | Nurphoto | Getty Photographs

Morgan Stanley is rolling out an innovative chatbot driven by OpenAI’s most current technologies to support the bank’s army of monetary advisors, CNBC has realized.

The financial institution has been screening the artificial intelligence instrument with 300 advisors and designs to roll it out extensively in the coming months, according to Jeff McMillan, head of analytics, data and innovation at the firm’s wealth management division.

similar investing news

Crypto just lost both of its main banks. Here's what it means for the industry going forward

CNBC Pro

Morgan Stanley’s shift is just one of the initial bulletins by a economic incumbent following the achievements of OpenAI’s ChatGPT, which went viral late very last year by producing human-sounding responses to questions. The financial institution is a juggernaut in wealth management with more than $4.2 trillion in customer assets. The guarantee and perils of artificial intelligence have been prepared about for yrs, but seemingly only soon after ChatGPT did mainstream end users understand the ramifications of the know-how.

The notion behind the tool, which has been in improvement for the earlier calendar year, is to help the bank’s 16,000 or so advisors tap the bank’s enormous repository of study and facts, explained McMillan.

“People want to be as educated as the smartest particular person” in our company, McMillan reported. “This is like possessing our chief system officer sitting future to you when you happen to be on the cell phone with a client.”

Whilst generative AI has dazzled customers and sparked a race amongst technologies giants to acquire merchandise, it has also led some buyers down weird paths. Final thirty day period, Morgan Stanley analysts wrote that ChatGPT once in a while “hallucinates and can produce answers that are seemingly convincing, but are really erroneous.”

Consumer guardrails

Comparable to ChatGPT, the device will immediately respond to thoughts for advisors. But it is centered on GPT 4, which is a additional state-of-the-art type of the know-how underpinning ChatGPT.

And as a substitute of the entire contents of the world wide web, this tool generates responses only on the 100,000 or so parts of analysis that Morgan Stanley has vetted for this use, which need to slash down on problems. To even further reduce mishaps, the financial institution has individuals checking the accuracy of responses, he explained.  

“We are hoping to basically break the platform” by human testing, he explained. “With superior-quality details, the better designs and an ongoing checking approach” the lender is self-assured in its new device, he reported.

The symbol of Morgan Stanley is witnessed in New York 

Shannon Stapleton | Reuters

The shift builds on previously endeavours by McMillan, such as the 2018 introduction of machine-finding out algorithms that prompt advisors to get to out to shoppers or just take other ways. With every new improvement, worry rises amid knowledge staff that engineering will be able to slash men and women out solely one day.

“I assume every single market is likely to be in some way disrupted for what I will describe as schedule, basic jobs,” McMillan reported.

But equipment can’t replace people when it will come to catering to advanced customers, he claimed.

“These things you should not have any empathy they are just extremely clever math that is capable to regurgitate knowledge,” he said.

Instant view: US intervenes to shore up SVB deposits, limit financial fallout

Instant view: US intervenes to shore up SVB deposits, limit financial fallout

March 13 (Reuters) – The U.S. governing administration introduced actions to shore up deposits and stem any broader financial fallout from the sudden collapse of tech startup-centered loan provider Silicon Valley Lender (SIVB.O) (SVB), sending U.S. stock futures bigger.

Adhering to are remarks from analysts and fund professionals:

CAROL SCHIELF, Main Expenditure OFFICER, BMO Relatives Workplace, MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA

“The amenities place in location to enable entry to non-insured deposits ought to enable back again quit an essential advancement engine of the economic climate which has by now been strained by higher funding expenditures, layoffs, and concerted initiatives to proper sizing businesses and check out income melt away charges.

“Ideally, this will allow for for a lot more discernment of midsized and regional bank shares than the babies-out-with-the-bathwater remedy the vast vast majority of the segment (obtained).

“Latest funding current market and stock/bond current market volatility may include to the totality of the knowledge and make it possible for the U.S. Fed area for a smaller hike. We do not hope them to pause just however.”

DEC MULLARKEY, Handling DIRECTOR, Financial commitment System & ASSET Spot, SLC Management, BOSTON:

Most recent Updates

Look at 2 a lot more tales

“The actions by the Fed to shore up the banking process with its new Bank Expression Funding Program (BTFP), is a decisive move. It will help stem volatility and considerably limit the threat of contagion. By allowing financial institutions to article Treasuries and other govt debt at par, (it) will aid loan companies stay clear of distress revenue and in transform honor deposits.

“The application is not a bail-out. Shareholders and unsecured debtholders will not be coated and in change will very likely see their positions get a considerable strike. As a end result, this system can be implemented quickly.

“Regional banking companies have been seeing considerable anxiety as marketplaces worried about a knock on. This move by the Fed affirms the resiliency of the program and that it has a apparent approach to guarantee liquidity and aid deposit holders.

ALVIN TAN, HEAD OF ASIA Forex Approach, RBC Cash Marketplaces, SINGAPORE:

“Marketplaces stay unsettled from the SVB failure. US and Uk regulators have stepped in to have the fallout.

“The industry turbulence sparked by SVB has upended mounting industry expectations on the Fed level route. We have US CPI because of on Tuesday, which adds to the uncertainty about the FOMC (Fed) conference up coming 7 days with the market place pulling back from anticipating a 50bp hike. The predicament is evolving, but volatility looks set to remain elevated in coming days.

ANTHONY SAGLIMBENE, Chief Marketplace STRATEGIST, AMERIPRISE Financial, TROY, MICHIGAN:

“It was imperative that regulators stepped in and decisively acted before markets all around the world opened for the 7 days. The truth that SVB and Signature Financial institution depositors will be made full is significant in protecting have faith in in the financial system and must aid stem contagion fears this 7 days. But Yellen produced incredibly apparent now that the governing administration will not bail out financial institution shareholders and some unsecured lenders, which really should make taxpayers delighted.

“In addition, the Fed’s facility to offer loans to banking companies that could see similar issues to SVB should also go a prolonged way in helping back again depositors and safeguard the money method.”

STEVE SOSNICK, Chief STRATEGIST, INTERACTIVE BROKERS, GREENWICH, CONNECTICUT

“The actions taken by regulators really should go a prolonged way to assuaging the crucial issues about deposits and customers’ ability to fulfill payroll and other obligations.

“It’s surely a tension reduction in the short-expression, and we can get worried about moral hazard and lax regulation afterwards.

“But it is way too before long to give an all clear. Inventory and bond holders in SVB and Signature are probable wiped out. That is a ton of dollars that simply just evaporated, which has to hurt somebody. It will not likely totally eliminate the concerns about what other banking companies could possibly be in difficulty.

“Long tale shorter, (it really is) great news for depositors and markets in the brief-term, but I you should not feel we are thoroughly out of the woods. But it also usually means that 50 basis points (a possible Fed desire charge hike) is off the table.”

CAROL KONG, Currency STRATEGIST, COMMONWEALTH Bank OF AUSTRALIA.

“Forex marketplaces are still digesting all the news related to the collapse of SVB. The actions declared this early morning appear to be to have calmed marketplaces for now and we are looking at some recovery in chance currencies. Presented all the actions taken by the authorities markets must be calmer at the very least for the time currently being, but if concerns about regional financial institutions, we could very easily see the greenback and Japanese yen rally once more.

“From the perspective of the FOMC, their problem is however inflation and inflation has not genuinely decelerated. Tomorrow’s CPI will keep on to display that inflation stays persistently large. Supplied what is actually transpired in the U.S. money process, a 25 foundation point hike is extra probably than a 50 basis stage hike.”

MATHAN SOMASUNDARAM, FOUNDER, DEEP Info ANALYTICS, SYDNEY:

“Even if they bail them out, it really is in essence saying that most of these banking institutions are carrying considerably increased chance than most men and women imagined.

Referring to irrespective of whether it could adjust the Federal Reserve’s charge tightening path, he claimed: “Prior to these lender collapses you would have imagined 50 basis details was in participate in? Does these banking institutions rolling around transform that? I do not consider so. At the stop of the day, the entire notion of what the Fed was undertaking was sooner or later going to crack things.

“The fact that at the 1st sign of a little something breaking, all people screams bailout, is a little bit premature. The Fed are not able to do bailouts or fee cuts or any type of pivot ’till they get inflation down so in principle they have to retain tightening and enable the weak spot engage in out.”

JUN BEI LIU, PORTFOLIO Supervisor, TRIBECA Financial investment Companions, SYDNEY:

“It was a major failure and plainly brought about buyers worry, but we assumed it was really corporation-distinct and about publicity to the pointy finish (of marketplaces). It can be not a systemic concern, at least at this place

“If the Fed is heading to guard the depositor, its probably nothing outside of what is actually occurring to corporations instantly associated.”

KARL SCHAMOTTA, Chief Sector STRATEGIST, CORPAY, TORONTO:

“We feel the actions taken by the Fed, Treasury and FDIC will decisively split the psychological ‘doom loop’ throughout the regional banking sector – and really should assist negate the likelihood of a funding squeeze in world marketplaces. But, fairly or not, the episode will add to larger amounts of history volatility, with investors observing warily for other cracks to emerge as the Fed’s coverage tightening proceeds.

“Terminal rate anticipations need to continue to be underneath the peaks attained through Powell’s testimony past Tuesday, with a far more cautious technique probably in the aftermath of this meltdown.”

SHANE OLIVER, HEAD OF Investment Technique, AMP Capital, SYDNEY:

“There is heading to be a large amount of to’ing and fro’ing in the current market in the next minor though to see if the steps work. The market is however quite nervous and this will get time to perform out.

“It would seem buyers are on edge considering if this financial institution has strike problems, probably there are many others that will be in hassle, far too. If it turns out to be a storm in a teacup and it’s in excess of in a 7 days, then the Fed subsequent 7 days will return to what it does which is looking at information and thinking about a 25 or 50 basis level maximize in prices. If there are nonetheless reverberations, then it would be difficult to do a 50 basis details hike even if CPI and retail product sales figures justify it.”

NICOLAS VERON, SENIOR FELLOW, THE PETERSON INSTITUTE FOR International ECONOMICS, WASHINGTON:

“This is a bailout and a major modify of the way in which the U.S. program was built and its incentives. The charge will be handed on to every person who makes use of banking expert services.

It’s feasible that the concern is that deposits have never ever moved so quickly and that is what fashioned the foundation of this selection – the outflows at SVB had been with out equivalent.

If all bank deposits are now insured, why do you want banking companies? This could feed into the debate about central financial institution electronic currencies.”

ECONOMISTS AT Capital ECONOMICS:

“These are sturdy moves. In distinct, the shift to accepting collateral at par alternatively than marking to industry suggests that the banking companies that have amassed much more than $600 billion in unrealised losses on their held-to-maturity Treasury and MBS securities portfolios – and failed to hedge the curiosity price danger – should really be capable to trip out the storm.

“Rationally, this must be enough to stop any contagion from spreading and taking down much more financial institutions, which can transpire in the blink of an eye in the electronic age. But contagion has often been additional about irrational panic, so we would strain that there is no promise this will operate.”

HOWARD NEEDLE, PORTFOLIO Manager AT WELLESLEY ASSET Administration, NEW YORK:

“In the shorter-expression a bailout should lessen panic but for a longer time term it can not be fantastic for the larger income center banking companies who will face a lot more stiff levels of competition from regional financial institutions, emboldened by the Fed support, as they can now act more aggressively to achieve and retain customers or deposits.”

JON SAKODA, FOUNDER OF EARLY-Phase Enterprise Company DECIBEL Companions, SAN FRANCISCO:

“This is a big step in restoring self-assurance in the startup local community. Right before this transfer numerous startups were being scheduling unexpected emergency steps which would have probably led to far more layoffs and furloughed staff members. The government’s actions have offered substantially essential certainty that every person can make payroll on Monday.”

MICHAEL PURVES, Main Government OFFICER AT TALLBACKEN Funds ADVISORS:

“What buyers have to hope coming into tomorrow and past is that we are likely to be working with a large amount of occasion risk. There are nonetheless likely to be lingering issues with other regional banking institutions.

“Less than these types of a such a situation, it can be tricky not to assume very significant-level volatility. If that comes about it’s actually tricky to imagine we are going to have an fairness rally.”

GREG MCBRIDE, Chief Fiscal ANALYST, BANKRATE:

“While the Fed has talked about a lot in the previous calendar year, right up until these days it has been in the context of monetary policy. But now the Fed functions in the potential of an even more crucial role, the lender of past vacation resort, to make positive financial institutions and credit unions have obtain to whatever income they want without the need of needing to sell high-good quality property that may possibly be buying and selling for fewer than confront value because of to the sharp boost in interest fees.

“Continue to to be established is the destiny of the property of Silicon Valley Bank. Irrespective of whether 1 purchaser, or multiple potential buyers, arise is nevertheless to be identified as of the second.”

Reporting by Carolina Mandl, Scott Murdoch, Krystal Hu, Shankar Ramakrishnan, Ira Iosebashvili, Megan Davies, Ankur Banerjee, Tom Westbrook, Herbert Lash, Saqib Ahmed, Elisa Martinuzzi and Rae Wee Producing by Anshuman Daga Editing by Kim Coghill and Bradley Perrett

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Have faith in Principles.

Financial Management: DOD Needs to Improve System Oversight

Financial Management: DOD Needs to Improve System Oversight

What GAO Found

For over 30 years, the Department of Defense (DOD) has initiated a variety of efforts and undergone several changes in organizational responsibility to help modernize its business and financial systems. However, these efforts and changes have not been fully successful to date. DOD is the only major federal agency to not achieve an unmodified (clean) audit opinion—its business and financial systems are a key impediment to this effort.

Effective oversight of systems is essential to moving DOD in the right direction. Key elements of such oversight include establishing oversight processes, using and communicating quality information, sustaining leadership commitment, and managing risk.

  • Oversight processes. DOD has established a process for overseeing its business and financial management systems. First, systems are not to proceed into development unless the approving official determines that statutory requirements have been met. These requirements are that the system (1) has been reengineered and streamlined, and unique software requirements and interfaces minimized, (2) complies with the defense business enterprise architecture, (3) has valid, achievable requirements, (4) has an acquisition strategy designed to eliminate or reduce the need to modify commercial off-the-shelf systems, and (5) complies with the Department’s auditability requirements. Second, once approved, systems proceed through an annual certification process in which DOD checks to make sure that systems are continuing to meet the requirements. However, the key guidance documents that govern DOD, military department, and defense agency decisions about initial approvals and annual certifications are limited. Specifically, the guidance does not fully address how systems are to document compliance or how decision-makers are to substantiate that systems are complying with requirements. For example, DOD-level guidance does not describe how approval authorities are to determine compliance with the auditability requirement. This places DOD at risk of making decisions based on a “check the box” exercise.

Extent to Which DOD, Military Department, and Defense Agency Guidance Addresses Initial Approval and Annual Certification Requirements for Covered Business Systems

Initial approval and Annual certification requirement

DOD

Army

Department of the Navy

Air Force

Defense Agencies

Business process reengineering

Business enterprise architecture

Requirement plan

Acquisition strategy

Auditability requirement

Legend:

● = Fully addressed: Guidance explains how systems are to address and decision-makers are to substantiate the initial approval and annual certification requirements.

◑ = Partially addressed: Guidance discusses at least one of the initial approval and annual certification requirements, but does not fully describe how systems are to address and decision-makers are to substantiate the requirements.

○ = Not addressed: Guidance does not discuss the requirements.

Source: GAO Analysis of Department of Defense (DOD) documentation. | GAO-23-104539

In addition, DOD does not apply key requirements to systems in sustainment, even though the statute does not provide for such an exclusion. By excluding application of these requirements, DOD may be missing important opportunities for improving these systems.

  • Quality information. As part of its oversight, DOD collects data about business and financial system compliance with statutory requirements. For example, of the 136 systems that indicated the auditability requirement was applicable or required, 84 indicated they were compliant with the requirement, 44 indicated they planned to comply, three indicated they were not compliant, and five indicated they had not completed an assessment.

Summary of DOD’s Data on Business System Compliance with Statutory Requirements

Compliance response

Business process reengineering

Business enterprise architecture

Requirement plan

Acquisition Strategy

Auditability

Compliance required or applicablea

189

192

66

67

136

No answer

1

1

1

1

1

Not required (Legacy system)b

18

15

21

20

Not required (System in sustainment)c

120

120

Not applicable

71

Total

208

208

208

208

208

Legend:

– = no responses under the specified category.

Source: GAO Analysis of Department of Defense (DOD) documentation. | GAO-23-104539

aSystems indicated that compliance with the requirement was required or applicable.

bDOD defines legacy systems as systems that it plans to phase out over the next 36 months. It does not require legacy systems to comply with certain requirements.

cDOD does not require systems that have proceeded past the development phase (i.e., systems in sustainment) to comply with selected requirements.

However, the reliability of these data is limited. For example, of the 208 systems that DOD identified as relevant to the financial audit, information on 71 systems indicated that the auditability requirement was not applicable to them. However, a separate database indicated that at least 58 of these 71 were relevant to the audit. In addition, as of January 2022, DOD reported that its Independent Public Auditors had identified 1,411 unresolved IT-related notices of findings and recommendations associated with 3,478 underlying IT-related issues. These results raises further questions about data reliability, which may also impact the extent of compliance with statutory requirements.

  • Leadership. DOD has experienced frequent changes to the organizations and entities responsible for overseeing its business and financial systems. For example, in February 2018 a new Chief Management Officer position was established with broad responsibilities for business operations; three years later the position was abolished. GAO has previously reported that demonstrating sustained, consistent leadership is imperative for successful business transformations.
  • Managing risk. Officials from across DOD provided their perspectives on risks and challenges facing the department as it seeks to modernize its financial system environment. These include legacy systems, system interfaces, and human capital. DOD has taken a number of steps to address risks and challenges identified by DOD officials. GAO will continue monitoring DOD’s efforts in this area.

In addition, DOD is not taking a strategic approach to managing the human capital needed for its financial management systems. It does not, among other things, analyze the gaps in capabilities between existing staff and future workforce needs, or formulate strategies for filling expected gaps. As a result, as discussed in the report, challenges have emerged.

Why GAO Did This Study

DOD spends billions of dollars each year on its business and financial systems. However, DOD’s business systems modernization and financial management efforts have been on GAO’s high risk list since 1995. These high risk areas remain obstacles to DOD’s efforts to achieve an unmodified audit opinion.

GAO was asked to review DOD’s financial management systems. This report (1) describes DOD’s efforts to improve its business and financial systems; (2) assesses the extent to which DOD is effectively overseeing its business and financial systems; and (3) assesses the extent to which DOD is taking a strategic approach to managing human capital for its financial management systems.

To describe DOD’s efforts to improve its business and financial systems, GAO reviewed related laws, GAO reports, and DOD and military department documentation associated with DOD’s business and financial systems.

To assess DOD’s oversight of these systems, GAO reviewed reports, guidance, and relevant statutes to identify key elements of business and financial management systems oversight. GAO evaluated DOD policy and DOD, military department, and defense agency guidance and plans against statutory requirements for oversight. It also evaluated DOD’s data on its systems’ compliance with statutory requirements associated with improving the department’s ability to obtain an unmodified audit opinion.

GAO also evaluated DOD and military department guidance and plans against key practices for workforce management. In addition, it interviewed relevant officials from DOD and the military departments